Part 2: The Third Child and the Grand Illusion

The office of Vance & Associates, Private Investigations, was suffocatingly quiet. The ticking of a grandfather clock in the corner sounded like a countdown to my own execution.

I stared at the wrinkled paper in my trembling hands.

“If Rowan ever discovers the truth, make sure he never learns what happened to the third baby.”

A third baby. Triplets. Maren hadn’t just given birth to twins on that lonely, agonizing week after I threw her out into the cold. She had carried three of my children. And one of them was gone.

“Where is the other child, Vance?” My voice didn’t sound like my own. It was a guttural whisper, raw with a mix of terror and boiling rage.

Arthur Vance, a man I had paid hundreds of thousands of dollars to protect my interests, wouldn’t look me in the eye. He reached for a glass of amber liquid on his desk, his hand noticeably shaking. “Rowan… you have to understand how the world works. Tessa Whitmore’s father owns half the real estate development contracts in this state. When she came to me with a blank check and a rewrite of your divorce dossier, I didn’t have a choice.”

I lunged across the desk, grabbing him by his silk tie, pulling his face inches from mine. “Where. Is. My. Child?”

“I don’t know!” Vance gasped, choking. “I swear to you, I don’t know! Tessa handled the medical staff herself. She paid off the attending obstetrician at the rural clinic in Maury County to falsify the records. The birth certificates you see there for the twins—those were the only ones Maren was allowed to keep. The third baby… Tessa took it. Or she disposed of it. I don’t know the details, Rowan, I swear!”

I threw him back into his leather chair. The disgust coating my throat was palpable. Every memory of the last twelve months flashed before my eyes like a grotesque horror movie.

Tessa smiling as she moved her designer luggage into my home.

Tessa comforting me when I drank myself to sleep, whispering that Maren was a gold-digging traitor.

Tessa picking out floral arrangements for a multi-million dollar wedding that was supposed to happen in less than three weeks.

She wasn’t a fiancé. She was a parasite who had systematically dismantled my life, stolen my children’s infancy from me, and left my wife to pick up aluminum cans on the side of a dusty Tennessee highway just to survive.

“If you breathe a word of this conversation to Tessa,” I whispered to Vance, my voice deadly calm, “I will use every dime of my net worth to ensure you spend the rest of your miserable life in a federal penitentiary. Do you understand me?”

Vance nodded frantically.

I grabbed the hidden file, shoved it inside my coat, and walked out into the cool night air.

The House of Lies
When I arrived back at my estate in Belle Meade, the lights were warmly glowing. From the outside, it looked like the picture-perfect home of a successful CEO. To me, it now looked like a mausoleum built on deceit.

I walked through the front door. The scent of expensive lavender and high-end cooking filled the air.

“Rowan, darling? Is that you?” Tessa’s melodic voice drifted from the kitchen.

She stepped out, wearing a flawless silk dress, a glass of white wine in her hand. Her smile was dazzling—the same smile that had completely blinded me for a year. “Where have you been? You missed dinner. I had the chef prepare that glazed salmon you love.”

I looked at her, forcing every muscle in my face to remain still. I had to play the part. If she realized I knew the truth, the location of our third child might be lost forever.

“Just… caught up in some late-year financial audits at the firm,” I lied, my voice tight. “A lot of loose ends to tie up before the wedding.”

Tessa walked over, wrapping her arms around my neck. The perfume she wore—the same scent I had paid thousands for—now made me want to gag. “Oh, don’t stress so much, honey. Soon, we’ll be married, and you can leave all that stress behind. Did you see how miserable Maren looked today? It just proves that karma always finds the people who wrong us.”

Karma, I thought, looking at the woman who had stolen my family. Yes. It certainly does.

“You’re right,” I managed to say, forcing a grim smile. “I’m going to wash up.”

I detached myself from her embrace and walked upstairs to my study. I locked the door, pulled out my laptop, and went to work. I couldn’t just confront her. I needed absolute leverage. I began tracing the financial transactions from the file Vance gave me, linking Tessa’s personal bank accounts to the shell companies used to frame Maren for corporate espionage.

But my mind kept drifting back to that dusty country road. To Maren’s tired, sorrowful eyes. And to those fair-haired twins.

I didn’t sleep that night. I spent the hours mapping out a plan. First, I had to find Maren and secure her safety and the twins. Second, I had to find out what happened to our third child. Third, I was going to destroy Tessa Whitmore entirely.

The Search for the Truth
The next morning, under the guise of an early morning corporate meeting, I drove straight back to Franklin. I didn’t know where Maren lived, but I knew where she had been walking.

I spent four hours driving down the rural backroads, asking local grocery store clerks, gas station attendants, and farmers if they recognized the woman with the twin babies. Finally, an old man at a hardware store nodded when I showed him a picture of Maren from my phone—an old picture from our happier days.

“Yeah, that’s Mary,” the old man said, mispronouncing her name. “She rents the old miller’s cabin down by the creek. Works odd jobs when she can, collects scrap. Real quiet girl. Has two beautiful little babies. Shame what happened to her husband—she told the landlord he passed away in a tragic accident.”

My chest tightened. Passed away. To Maren, the man I used to be was dead. And honestly, she wasn’t wrong.

I followed the old man’s directions down a winding dirt path heavily canopy-covered by oak trees. At the end of the trail sat a small, weathered wooden cabin. The porch was uneven, but it was clean. A couple of cheap plastic baby toys sat near the front door.

I parked my SUV and stepped out. My heart hammered against my ribs like a trapped bird.

As I approached the porch, the screen door creaked open. Maren stepped out. She was wearing the same faded jeans, holding a basket of clean laundry. When she saw my face, she froze. The color drained from her cheeks.

“Rowan,” she whispered. Her voice held no anger—only a profound, crushing exhaustion. “What are you doing here? Did your fiancée lose another twenty dollars?”

“Maren, please,” I said, taking a step forward, raising my hands in surrender. “I’m not here to hurt you. I’m not here to mock you.”

“Then leave,” she said coldly, turning back toward the door. “You took my dignity, you took my reputation, and you threw me out like trash based on lies you were too arrogant to question. You have your perfect life, Rowan. Leave me to mine.”

“I know about Tessa,” I shouted before she could close the door.

Maren stopped. Her back was stiff.

“I know she framed you,” I continued, tears finally blurring my vision. “I went to Vance last night. I found the real files. I know the hotel photos were staged. I know the necklace was planted. I know everything, Maren. I am so, so incredibly sorry. I was a fool. A blind, prideful fool.”

Slowly, Maren turned around. Her eyes searched my face, looking for a trap, looking for the malice she had grown to expect. When she saw the genuine agony in my expression, her shoulders sank.

“You’re a year too late, Rowan,” she said softly, a tear escaping her eye. “A year too late.”

“I know,” I sobbed, dropping to my knees right there on her porch. “I know I don’t deserve your forgiveness. I don’t expect it. But please… let me help you. Let me fix this.”

Maren walked down the steps and stood over me. “You can’t fix a broken glass, Rowan. You can only cut yourself trying to pick up the pieces.”

“The twins,” I looked up at her, my voice trembling. “They’re mine, aren’t they?”

Maren closed her eyes and nodded slowly. “Liam and Noel. They turned ten months old last week. I didn’t tell you because… because the day I discovered I was pregnant was the day your lawyers delivered the final divorce decree. You told the press I was a thief. I knew if I told you about them, you or Tessa would use your power to take them away from me. I couldn’t risk losing them.”

I covered my face with my hands, weeping openly on the porch steps of a dilapidated cabin. My children. My beautiful children, living in poverty because of my stupidity.

Then, I wiped my eyes and looked at her, the most terrifying question of my life burning on my tongue.

“Maren… what about the third baby?”

See more on the next page